such_heights: amy and rory looking at a pile of post (who: little blue box [gemstar69])
Amy ([personal profile] such_heights) wrote2009-12-25 07:30 pm

Doctor Who

Well! I think my primary reaction is 'omg can it be next week now???' I don't feel like I can really judge this on its own merits, I need to see how it ends. Some scattered thoughts:

+ WILF. WIIIILF. HE IS AMAZING AND I WANT HIM TO BE MY GRANDDAD. Ahem. Yes. <3

+ Donna! Oh, Donna, I am so worried for you and your nice fiancé. D: THEORY: the everyone turning into the Master thing didn't work on her because she is not, in fact, fully human. See, if I were writing the show that would mean that she must help the Doctor save the world by embracing her Time Lady-ness, and then going on her merry, superpowered way. However, I know this will not happen. *clings to Donna*

+ In general, I fear much fail next week. Yeah, it's a finale, what else is new, I know. :(

+ The Master tied up, the Master gagged, the Master on a lead, the Master in a dress. Thank you, show!

+ I don't know what other people's reactions are going to be, but I personally thought the Obama running thing about a speech that's going to save the world was pretty funny. Also, nice job on the sound-alike voice in particular, that was fun.

+ I think by far the best moment of the episode was the conversation between Wilf and the Doctor in the cafe. It was actually a really nice, understated bit of Ten angst, much better than the usual fare. <3

+ Okay, I loved Wilf and his friends and the Silver Cloak, that was wonderful. Yay for older people getting things to do! And I'm glad to see the older woman in the white suit who's speaking to Wilf, hopefully she won't be power-mad and need to be taken down the way they normally are.

+ GALLIFREY OMGWTFBBQ. Just, what. Okay, THEORY: the Time Lords do not, in fact, want to END TIME (because that doesn't make any sense), rather, they want to end this timeline as a way of correcting the Doctor's mistakes/restoring Gallifrey to its former glory/defeating the Daleks forever/insert option here. This will be a reset that brings back Gallifrey and undoes a reasonable amount of the RTD era, e.g. the amount of common human knowledge about aliens, which will be the set-up for the Moffat era. /theory.

+ My friends, your thoughts? I cannot process this alone!
magic_at_mungos: (where were we by radiogaga80)

[personal profile] magic_at_mungos 2009-12-25 10:34 pm (UTC)(link)
Wilf was indeed wonderful. Plus my theory is that people who have travelled in the TARDIS won't change because it's changed their molecular cells slightly.
magic_at_mungos: (whatever by etacanis)

[personal profile] magic_at_mungos 2009-12-26 12:08 pm (UTC)(link)
That explains why Wilf and Donna didn't change. Somewhere there's Martha and Sarah-Jane going h for fuck's sake, what has he done now?
beck_liz: Doctor Who: Ten & Donna back-to-back (DW - 10 & Donna)

[personal profile] beck_liz 2009-12-26 04:32 pm (UTC)(link)
I'm pretty sure Wilf didn't get changed because he was inside that whatsis chamber, actually, and Donna didn't get changed for the same reason the Doctor didn't; she's got a little Gallifreyan inside her and the presto-chango device was programmed for humans only.

So as nice as it might be to think that Martha & Sarah Jane are safe, I don't think they are.
magic_at_mungos: (whatever by etacanis)

[personal profile] magic_at_mungos 2009-12-27 11:56 am (UTC)(link)
I want to think that's true but am aware I was probably overthinking it.

Bt it would be cool but I'm sure Rusty didn't think about it much! )
tea: Barbara Gordon/Oracle, pushing her hair back. (Default)

[personal profile] tea 2009-12-26 04:32 pm (UTC)(link)
I actually think he didn't change because the Doctor put him in that insulating box thing. I.e. when he said he could see again, the Doctor had interfered with the signal so it wouldn't affect him.
magic_at_mungos: (emilia fox by burgandy_shoes)

[personal profile] magic_at_mungos 2009-12-27 11:57 am (UTC)(link)
Which is probably the case. I just wanted Sarah Jane and Martha to be all right and be awesome and help save the day.
snorkackcatcher: (Default)

[personal profile] snorkackcatcher 2009-12-28 02:01 pm (UTC)(link)
Agree with [personal profile] beck_liz and others -- Donna and the Hand actually metastazized/whatever, so she isn't entirely human. It would have been interesting to see what would happen to Jack, mind you (and what a Jack!Master would revive as if killed), but presumably he's still off the planet. I imagine Martha, Sarah, Gwen, and the rest would be affected, even Luke (which is a good way of not having to write in a role for them, after all). Mind you, there should be a number of aliens and part-aliens knocking around unaffected, especially around Cardiff ... It would be fairly awesome to see Wilf and Mr Copper team up to help the Doctor save the day, but I doubt that's going to happen. :)

My guess for Donna's part to play in all this is that the Doctor actually is going to get properly killed, but Romana Random Lady In White is going to use the template stored as part of DoctorDonna to bring him back in the same way as the Master was brought back using the ring?