such_heights: the enterprise orbits a planet, text reads 'boldly go' (trek: boldy go [427])
Amy ([personal profile] such_heights) wrote2009-06-20 12:59 am

Star Trek Rewatch -- The Corbomite Maneuver



Exploring a distant region of space, the Enterprise is threatened by Balok, commander of a starship from the First Federation. [Memory Alpha]



The episode opens with Spock in command of the bridge. The Enterprise is conducting stellar cartography of uncharted regions of space. Spock seems to be having a pretty good time, in a Vulcan sort of way, but navigator Bailey is less impressed.



Sulu then detects an approaching object, which proves to be a mysterious cube.



It's on a collision course with the Enterprise, and it follows the ship as Sulu launches evasive manoeuvres. As it becomes apparent that they cannot shake the object off, the ship goes into red alert.



Meanwhile, Kirk's in sickbay undergoing a physical. McCoy neglects to inform of the alert until he's done, but when Kirk sees the summons he's in such a hurry to get to the bridge that putting a shirt on is much too much like hard work.



One imagines this is a customary sight for the crew of the Enterprise.



Spock figures that the cube is either a buoy or a trap, and so Kirk decides it's time they got out of there.



When the Enterprise tries to fly past it, the cube starts emitting slowly-building radiation, which increase however fast the ship tries to escape. Finally, Kirk gives the order to fire, destroying the cube.

Immediate danger over, Kirk decides that the ship should press on ahead to see what life is out there that might make such a thing. Meanwhile, Sulu and Bailey organise drills to increase the crew's response time, and McCoy berates Kirk for promoting Bailey rapidly, claiming that Bailey's very similar to the Kirk of eleven years ago.



They then go back to Kirk's quarters, where Yeoman Rand enters to sport a fetching beehive hairdo and prompt the requisite genderfail of the episode.



They're interrupted when a new object appears on sensors - a much larger sphere.



It introduces itself as the ship Fesarius, flagship of the First Federation and commanded by Balok.



Balok accuses the Enterprise of malevolent intent, and when they try to send a message out he interprets it as a hostile act and gives the crew ten minutes to live, having shut down all engines and weapons capabilities via a tractor beam.

Kirk tries to get through to him, explaining that he means no harm, but Balok simply replies with a countdown. Bailey cracks under the pressure and is escorted from the bridge.



After conversations with Spock and McCoy, Kirk decides to out-bluff Balok.



He concocts a mystery Federation weapon, corbomite. It's a substance that deflects any weapons fired on Federation ships, so strongly that it destroys their aggressors. No one has survived an attempted attack on an Earth ship in 200 years.



Tension mounts, the timer runs down, and Bailey returns to the bridge, requesting to retake his post. The crew gather round, quietly waiting, together.



Balok announces that the Enterprise's destruction has been delayed and that instead they are to be taken back to the First Federation to be interred. A smaller ship launches from the sphere and starts to tow the Enterprise away.



Kirk waits for his moment then strains the engines well beyond capacity until eventually the ship swings free. It comes to a halt, and then Uhura detects a distress signal from Balok's ship saying that engines and life support are down. The signal's so weak there's no way it's going to reach his people.

Kirk decides to go back for a rescue operation, taking McCoy and Bailey with him.



When they beam onto the ship they find that the fearsome Balok is in fact a dummy, an alter ego for the real, child-like Balok, who welcomes them enthusiastically and offers them drinks.



He tells them that the whole experience was a test in order to assess their true intentions, and that he desires to continue an exchange of cultures.



Though initially bemused, the away team warm to Balok, and when Kirk says he'd be happy to spare a crew member, he looks at Bailey meaningfully, who readily agrees to stay behind. The episode ends with Balok happily taking the three on a tour of his ship.

*

Trivia:

This marks the first appearances of Uhura, Rand, and McCoy.

Our first McCoy-ism! "What am I, a doctor or a moon shuttle conductor?" Also, Kirk refers to McCoy as saying that suffering is good for the soul, a line used again in the 2009 film.

Uhura says "hailing frequencies open, sir," really kind of a lot here, heh.

Spock also refers to his human mother, more in keeping with his established backstory than the pilot episode.

You really get a sense of the Kirk-Spock-McCoy triumvirate, the way the three of them work together.

*

I liked this one a lot! Genuine suspense in the plotting -- although, given how much of a trope the reveal at the end is by modern sci-fi standards, you could kind of see it coming. And throughout there was character development, a lot of nice team-y moments, and the first real look at the Federation's stated commitment to peacefully seeking out new life.

[identity profile] ignipes.livejournal.com 2009-06-20 12:13 am (UTC)(link)
Thanks to [personal profile] thistlerose, I can't help but think of this episode as "the one in which the Enterprise is menaced by CAT TOYS IN SPACE."
jeeps: (st:aos ♡ gqmf lensflares)

[personal profile] jeeps 2009-06-20 09:10 pm (UTC)(link)
personally, it evoked a certain windows screen saver for me. i ended up falling over laughing every time they showed it on the viewscreen. OH, THE FUTURE.
silveronthetree: R2D2 (Default)

[personal profile] silveronthetree 2009-06-20 11:23 pm (UTC)(link)
Yes! I thought exactly the same thing. It was hard to take being menaced by screensavers seriously.
nicolasechs: (star trek crew)

[personal profile] nicolasechs 2009-06-20 12:46 am (UTC)(link)
Wow, that is one gleaming chest. I... can't really look away.
andreth47: (Jim!!)

[personal profile] andreth47 2009-06-20 01:46 am (UTC)(link)
Been lurking a bit on these rewatches, but I've gotta come out of the shadows for this one! This is really the ep where Star Trek becomes the Star Trek I loved, where the Kirk/Spock/Bones dynamic really gets going, as you say. So great! Gives me warm fuzzies.

Is this the first appearance of the chess vs. poker metaphor that runs through the series? It's such a gorgeous metaphor for Spock and Kirk themselves.

You didn't mention the TRANYA!! ;D

(I also always got a kick out of the fact that the actor who played Bailey went on to play Dorian's husband Herb in, oh god, was it 'All My Children'? He was a decent actor, always liked him)
andreth47: (Chest hair)

[personal profile] andreth47 2009-06-20 01:50 am (UTC)(link)
And on the shallow end of the pool, may I just add...omg, Spock is HOT. Woof.
gorgeousnerd: A cartoon Batman from "Batman and Sons" holding his baby Terry, smiling and whistling. (Batman.)

[personal profile] gorgeousnerd 2009-06-20 03:04 am (UTC)(link)
I went a little Trek-crazy this week. It was partially because I enjoyed this episode a lot, and it was partially that I rediscovered pictures of Star Trek: The Experience on my computer. So here's my links for the week:

-The Corbomite Maneuver: The Watch-Along. I actually wrote more of a summary of what was going on than I did for "Where No Man Has Gone Before", so I think it's somewhat easier to follow.

-Star Trek: The Experience. I went last August, and I just now uploaded some pictures from it. They had an extensive museum area before the rides, and that's most of what the pictures are from.

-Star Trek reboot art meme. Warning: crappy art ahead.
copracat: mirror universe spock holding a gun on kirk with text "this is not our fate" (spock not our fate)

[personal profile] copracat 2009-06-20 03:23 am (UTC)(link)
What DID they spray on Shatner to get that healthy glow?

[identity profile] ignipes.livejournal.com 2009-06-20 09:02 pm (UTC)(link)
I wonder that every single time he takes his shirt off. Oil? Butter? His own special concoction of naked-shine-a-lot? THE WORLD MAY NEVER KNOW.
copracat: shirtless joe flanigan in the sunshine, cap from Dawson's Creek (joe)

[personal profile] copracat 2009-06-20 11:43 pm (UTC)(link)
I guess he'd be nice and slippy. I wonder if he waxed or shaved?
lorannah: (spock)

[personal profile] lorannah 2009-06-20 07:24 pm (UTC)(link)
Am going to pretend that it hasn't taken over two hours for me to watch this episode (flipping buffering)

Really enjoyed this episode. Particularly McCoy - enjoying him as the gruff sensitive one of the triumvirate. For some reason in my head it's only Kirk who has to have quarterly physicals - the rest of the crew just do them yearly - mostly because McCoy likes to torture him. Also I am very amused that the crew completely fails to react to their Captain walking around topless - I can see this being true in the reboot verse as well.

Feels like the crew is starting to slot into place, though it still feels to me like they're working out what to do with Spock.

And have to say I absolutely loved:

"He's starting a countdown!" - because massive lols.
tmtrx: (k/s-legendary)

[personal profile] tmtrx 2009-06-20 10:29 pm (UTC)(link)
And have to say I absolutely loved:

"He's starting a countdown!" - because massive lols.


That whole countdown thing with Sulu was very funny. "If anyone wants to know..." hee.
silveronthetree: R2D2 (Default)

[personal profile] silveronthetree 2009-06-20 11:42 pm (UTC)(link)
Am going to pretend that it hasn't taken over two hours for me to watch this episode (flipping buffering)

You too? It was driving me crazy, I kept losing the thread of the plot.

[identity profile] ignipes.livejournal.com 2009-06-20 09:05 pm (UTC)(link)
Okay, actual commentary now: I really like this episode! I felt it was a bit slow in places and the ending was rushed (and that baby-dude was a bit creepy), but I love the story of finding mysterious objects and beings in space and the crew/captain really being at a loss for how to deal with them.

Sulu is, as always, awesome. He so calm in the face of Countdowns of Doom. ♥

I also loved the interaction between Kirk and McCoy when they were talking about what to do about Bailey. I imagine they have a lot of conversations like that, because they don't always agree but they tend to trust each other's judgment.

My favorite line was when Bailey said something about having adrenaline and Spock replied, "That sounds inconvenient. You should think about having it removed." :DDDDD
tmtrx: (k/s-legendary)

[personal profile] tmtrx 2009-06-20 10:27 pm (UTC)(link)
This episode was way better than I remembered. I have no idea why I didn't like remember most of it, but possibly because I didn't have it taped with the rest.

I about died laughing when I realized Kirk was walking out of sickbay without his shirt on and carrying his boots. I tend to think of Kirk as way more aware of keeping his crew's respect than that. So I have a feeling Shatner had something to do with that scene. LOL

And poor Uhura. I can't wait for her to get rid of that horrible gold. She looks much prettier in the red. And I think someone needs to keep track of how many times she actually says "hailing frequencies open" because it was getting ridiculous.

Here's the link to my DW post. I wrote down a few things while I was watching and made a few icon bases. Mostly of Spock this time.
sherrold: TOS: Kirk trying to convince Spock of something; Spock looking dubious (tos-galileo)

This is adorable!

[personal profile] sherrold 2009-06-21 04:43 am (UTC)(link)
Wow, I'd never remembered that this was Bones' first episode (and I'm the sort of person who could tell you which episode he used "green-blooded" as an epithet). Lovely picts, and thanks for all the reminders of their interactions. I was a big gen team girl for years before I'd ever even heard of k/s...
ext_29272: (Default)

[identity profile] sunnyrea.livejournal.com 2009-07-02 02:45 pm (UTC)(link)
*belated commenting*

Seriously, how many good lines are there in this episode? Its a giggle-fest!!